Back to BlogAverage salary: $35,000-$60,000/year Benefits: +30-40% Total cost: $45,000-$84,000/year Cost: $0-$99/month Annual cost: $0-$1,188 Savings: $44,000-$83,000/year Repetitive tasks 24/7 availability Instant response time Scaling infinitely Consistent quality Complex judgment calls Emotional intelligence Creative problem-solving Building relationships Nuanced communication
AI & AutomationJanuary 10, 202510 min read
AI Personal Assistant vs Human Assistant: Full Comparison
An honest comparison of AI and human assistants—costs, capabilities, and which is right for your needs.
A
Astra Team
Astra Team
AI Personal Assistant vs Human Assistant: Full Comparison
Choosing between an AI assistant and a human assistant? Here's everything you need to know.
Cost Comparison
Human Assistant
AI Assistant (Astra)
Capabilities
What AI Assistants Excel At:
What Human Assistants Excel At:
The Verdict
For most routine tasks, AI assistants provide incredible value at a fraction of the cost. Human assistants remain valuable for high-touch, relationship-driven work.
The ideal solution? Use AI for routine tasks and invest human time in high-value work.
Ready to try AI phone calls?
Download Astra and make your first automated phone call today.
Get Started Free